Otterbox vs Lifeproof

Otterbox vs. LifeProof for iPhone 5S

Let’s be honest: If you are looking for an iPhone case that can keep your digital best friend dry, even when dropped in a pool, there are two brands that come to mind; Otterbox and LifeProof. Today I’m going to compare both brands to help you figure out which one is for you!

 

eBags

Otterbox Defender

Otterbox Defender Case for iPhone 5S – $16.97

The name Otterbox has become synonymous with cell phone protection. They are the #1 selling phone case in the U.S. and Canada, so they’re obviously doing something right. Their top-of-the-line Preserver series for the iPhone 5 is no exception.

Features:

  • It’s a two-piece case that snaps together for easy assembly
  • Solid, sturdy case with overmolded synthetic bumpers that absorb impact force
  • Built-in screen protector guards the touch screen against scratches
  • Internal foam provides cushioning and holds the device in place
  • Adjustable lanyard is included for convenient carrying and tethering
  • Waterproof: fully submergible up to 6.6 ft. (2 m) for 30 minutes
  • Drop proof: protects device from drops up to 6.6 ft. (2 m)
  • Dust proof: blocks entry of dust and debris particles

 

Pros:

  • I was incredibly impressed with how sturdy this case was. Opening the case, even just to get my phone out, was not easy. There was no doubt the case would hold up, even when dropped.
  • The touch screen was still very responsive despite a film of plastic covering the screen.
  • The bottom rubber flaps gave full access to all ports.

 

Cons:

  • This case adds a LOT of bulk to the phone. It’s definitely brawn over beauty.
  • If you like to take your phone out of the case often, this is NOT the case for you. It is not easy.
  • Without any “snap” when closing the rubber flaps over the ports, you can’t really tell if the seal is tight. There’s a lot of room for human error
  • The touch screen was responsive…but every so often it wouldn’t detect touches.
  • L-shaped headphone jacks don’t fit case.

 

LifeProof Nuud Case for iPhone 5S

Lifeproof nuud Case for iPhone 5S – $90

LifeProof made a HUGE splash with their Nuud line of products. Long story short, they realized that since screens we waterproof, they just had to create a water-tight seal around the screen, allowing you to touch your actual screen while keeping your phone/ipad waterproof!

Features:

  • The thinnest, lightest all-protective iPhone 5 case ever made
  • Screenless technology lets you touch your iPhone 5’s actual touchscreen
  • Waterproof: Fully submersible to 6.6 feet (2m)
  • Dirt proof: Totally sealed from dirt and dust
  • Snow proof: Completely closed to snow and ice
  • Shockproof: Survives drops from 6.6 feet (2m)

 

Pros:

  • Thin design keeps a slim profile while maintaining waterproof design.
  • No loss in touch sensitivity since you’re touching your actual screen.
  • Easier to open to get to my phone.
  • Very responsive button controls.

 

Cons:

  • L-shaped headphone jacks don’t fit case.
  • Have to apply a separate screen protector if you want to avoid scratches
  • Thinner design makes phone slightly more vulnerable on falls

eBags

a Rafflecopter giveaway

About TripKnowledgy

My name is Spencer Howard, and I’m an Concierge/Host/Drunk who has spent the majority of the past 9 years on the road, hopping from hotel to hotel for months at a time. Through trial and mostly error, I’ve become what the airport security line calls an “Expert Traveler.” (It makes my Mother proud) But for those of us who go beyond occasional puddle jumper and enter the world of Hotel Homebody, it takes more than a complimentary mint and a flat screen TV to warm the cockles of our hearts. I hope you have insurance, because I'm gonna be throwing some knowledge bombs at your face. **Feel free to contact me with your questions about Travel Gadgets & Gear**

View all post by TripKnowledgy »

5 Comments
  1. Sarah

    March 12, 2014

    My dad needs one of these so bad! If I win it going to him!

  2. Megan Kennedy

    March 17, 2014

    The Otterbox looks like it would be best for me! I like the idea of having my screen protected.

  3. Alex Patti

    July 25, 2015

    The life proof is the best case for my iPhone 5s because I’m kind of clumsy.

  4. Jenn

    July 8, 2016

    Otter box all the way!! And my sons I phone 6 was dropped in a creek and still survived. And he had even left it in the case with water for an hour!!! (He’s 10) lol we just took it out and didn’t turn it on for 48 hours. Good as new! Cannot beat this case for dropping incidents!!!

Leave your comment